• Home
  • About
    • Authors
  • Articles
    • Archives
    • Chaplain
    • Crime & Controversy
    • Community
    • Cop Humor
    • Editorial
    • Op-ed
    • Gear & Technology
    • Investigations
    • Laws & Legal
    • Leadership
    • News
    • Officer Down
    • On Duty
    • Tactics
  • Network
    • Illinois Network
    • Minneapolis Network
    • Tulsa Network
    • Wauwatosa Network
    • Learn more
  • Training
  • Officer Privacy
  • Jobs
  • Contact
No Result
View All Result
Law Officer
Law Officer
No Result
View All Result

Qualified immunity is an endangered species

Texas police sergeant

(Edward Kimmel)

April 2, 2021
Dan LlorensbyDan Llorens
Share and speak up for justice, law & order...

The Big Apple’s shot callers, citing the need for justice for victims of police violence, recently voted to abolish qualified immunity for NYPD’s crime fighters. Democrat members of the House unilaterally rammed through H.R. 1280 last month, seeking to end qualified immunity for law enforcement officers nationwide. Its fate in the Senate is uncertain, but President Joe Biden, who a few months ago wondered aloud why officers couldn’t avoid unpleasant fatal shootings by simply wounding offenders in the leg, is likely to look on such legislation favorably. Qualified immunity, and the protection it provides officers from frivolous civil suits, has never looked more endangered.

What’s qualified immunity and why shouldn’t our collective eyes glaze over when we read about it? Qualified immunity has protected generations of officers since the late 1960’s from spending nights sleeplessly staring at ceiling tiles, wondering if their family would be financially ruined. In short, qualified immunity is a legal doctrine that protects officers from civil lawsuits by applying a two-pronged test to claim by a plaintiff: (1) did the officer violate a person’s Constitutional rights, and (2), did the officer’s actions violate a clearly established law or rule?

Only if the court rules the facts presented justify a “yes” to both questions may the lawsuit properly proceed.

Critics of qualified immunity claim the doctrine of qualified immunity is not ensconced anywhere in the U.S. Constitution or in any federal statue, as it was a creation of the U.S. Supreme Court in 1967. They claim the doctrine has allowed officers to avoid accountability and keeps victims from obtaining justice by protecting the sometimes unconstitutional but not clearly established behavior of out-of-control police officers.

Every police academy law instructor has probably taught, “Bad facts make bad law.” This truism is perfectly illustrated today as opponents of qualified immunity point to dozens of correctly decided qualified immunity cases whose facts nonetheless should make any good cop uncomfortable.

Eliminating qualified immunity due to a small sample of cases since 1967 (as compared to all arrests made or uses of force since that time), would open the floodgates to lawsuits as every decision an officer makes is profitably dragged into the nearest federal courthouse.  Even some proponents of abolishing qualified immunity admit it would increase the number of lawsuits against police. This is why any legislation ending qualified immunity is, in practice, the Plaintiff Attorneys Full Employment Act of 2021.

Congressional Democrats formally labeled H.R. 1280 after George Floyd, a standard political maneuver that like most such tactics is heavy on emotion and light on context.  As the nation watches Derek Chauvin’s broadcast murder trial, where he faces some 40 years in prison for the death of Mr. Floyd, who can say we are not watching justice being served?  If qualified immunity goes away, police officers across the country will once again pay with their lives and livelihood for the sins of others. That’s neither justice nor just.


Share and speak up for justice, law & order...
Tags: Dan LlorensH.R. 1280must-readqualified immunity
Dan Llorens

Dan Llorens

After serving as an Infantryman in the U.S. Marine Corps, Dan Llorens was fortuitously hired by the Fountain Valley (CA) Police Department in 1988 and found a lifelong desire to serve and protect.  Dan’s early assignments included SWAT, gang investigator and field training officer. As his responsibilities and rank increased, Dan oversaw the Special Investigations Unit (narcotics and vice), steered the department’s transition towards a regional SWAT team, and the creation of a school resource officer program.  Dan also took the lead in establishing the department’s policing philosophy based upon a data-driven approach to crime and traffic safety. In 2011, Dan was honored to be sworn in as Fountain Valley’s fifth police chief and focused on repeat offenders, homeless outreach, the use of technology and social media. Looking for new challenges, Dan retired from Fountain Valley in 2017 and accepted a position as assistant police chief (operations) with the Los Angeles Airport Police, overseeing the day-to-day airport protection duties of over 800 law enforcement professionals at LAX and Van Nuys. Among other educational pursuits, Dan received a Doctorate in Organizational Leadership from Brandman University. Dan left active law enforcement in 2020, and now focuses on faith, family, and writing on law enforcement topics.

Related Posts

Steve Nothem

Texas police officer dies after being struck by vehicle during DUI investigation

October 19, 2022
Bristol officer

Connecticut Inspector General’s Office releases heroic bodycam footage of Bristol officer-involved shooting

October 18, 2022
San Antonio officer

Experts weigh in after 5th San Antonio officer dies by suicide in past 7 months

October 17, 2022
Natalie Young

California police sergeant pins badge on 22-year-old woman he saved as a baby

October 11, 2022
rape

Los Angeles to explore creation of ‘Office of Unarmed Response’ to replace police on certain calls

October 9, 2022
civility

Derek Chauvin claims riots ‘poisoned’ jury in George Floyd case

October 9, 2022
Load More

Latest Articles

Alejandro Mayorkas

Lawmaker files impeachment against head of Homeland Security over border crisis

June 8, 2023
vile consequences

More Vile Consequences of Not Enforcing the Laws Equally

June 8, 2023
Wilson Chavis

Funeral company owner fatally shoots pallbearer during burial service over prior business dispute

June 8, 2023
Ivori H Howard

Woman crawls beneath security fence at Houston airport, brings operations to a standstill

June 8, 2023
Larry Bryant

Georgia man sentenced to 20 years in prison for shooting at state troopers after crashing car during pursuit

June 8, 2023
Adam Fravel

Man charged with murder two months after mother of his children mysteriously vanished

June 8, 2023
Load More

Weekly E-Newsletter

Subscribe—and get the latest news and editorials direct from Law Officer each week!

[newsletter_form type="minimal"]

JOIN THE FIGHT

BE COURAGEOUS

FIND MORE…

Law Officer

© 2021 LawOfficer.com

LawOfficer.com

  • Home
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy Policy
  • Corrections
  • Contact

Speak up for justice, law & order

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • About
    • Authors
  • Articles
    • Archives
    • Chaplain
    • Crime & Controversy
    • Community
    • Cop Humor
    • Editorial
    • Op-ed
    • Gear & Technology
    • Investigations
    • Laws & Legal
    • Leadership
    • News
    • Officer Down
    • On Duty
    • Tactics
  • Network
    • Illinois Network
    • Minneapolis Network
    • Tulsa Network
    • Wauwatosa Network
    • Learn more
  • Training
  • Officer Privacy
  • Jobs
  • Contact

© 2021 LawOfficer.com