• Home
  • About
    • Authors
  • Articles
    • Archives
    • Chaplain
    • Crime & Controversy
    • Community
    • Cop Humor
    • Editorial
    • Op-ed
    • Gear & Technology
    • Investigations
    • Laws & Legal
    • Leadership
    • News
    • Officer Down
    • On Duty
    • Tactics
  • Network
    • Illinois Network
    • Minneapolis Network
    • Tulsa Network
    • Wauwatosa Network
    • Learn more
  • Training
  • Jobs
  • Contact
No Result
View All Result
Law Officer
Law Officer
No Result
View All Result

Appeals Court Hears Lawsuit Against Heroic Police Work

Heroic Police Work
June 28, 2022
Law Officer NetworkbyLaw Officer Network
Share and speak up for justice, law & order...

Los Angeles Police Officer Toni McBride was confronted by a man holding a box cutter. She shot him six times. That sentence is often enough to start a riot in many communities, but there is much, much more to the story.

McBride arrived at a chaotic five-car crash with multiple occupants and injuries. Many bystanders arrived and added to the number of citizens whose needs and voices demanded attention. Witnesses quickly pointed to a man in a pickup truck, later identified as Daniel Hernandez, and shouted that he caused the crash, had a knife and was wanting to hurt himself.

Now McBride is dealing with a reportedly armed man as well as the crumpled cars and injured persons who apparently were intentionally harmed by Hernandez. She ordered Hernandez to come out of the truck. When he did, he moved swiftly toward McBride, displaying the edged weapon. Before assisting officers could arrive, McBride faced not one decision but many.

Was this person mentally disturbed and could he be talked into compliance? Was he a threat to others nearby as well as to the officer and himself? Would any of the bystanders interfere? McBride had already had to order persons who approached her to get back. She did so to keep them out of the danger zone, but also to avoid being a distraction from her attacker. She had the presence of mind to make the order in both English and Spanish.

McBride drew her service weapon to augment her demands for Hernandez to stop, along with her upheld non-gun hand to signal him to come no closer. She backed up as far as she could and still maintain control over her position in the encounter. Hernandez continued to advance rapidly toward her in what multiple video captures show was unquestionably aggressive.

Some would question at this point what threat a box cutter could be against a well-trained police officer with a handgun and other weapons available to her. Those who have not faced the results of an edged weapon against flesh may not realize the serious threat posed by the little box cutter (described in this case as a small folding type knife). The swiftness and seriousness of injuries from such a weapon can cause rapid blood loss, loss of vision if directed toward the face, and loss of muscle and nerve control needed to execute arrest techniques and operate handcuffs and weapons.

So, Officer McBride fired two shots from her service weapon, striking Hernandez with both. He fell, but almost immediately rose to his knees in a runner’s crouch, intent on completing his mission of attacking the officer and, in all likelihood, forcing her to kill him as a means of death by suicidal intent. As he poised to resume his attack, McBride fired a volley of four additional rounds that stopped the man, killing him.

Any headline that minimizes the officer’s complex decision such as the LA Times headline that read “He had a box cutter, ignored commands, and a cop shot him six times. Were there better options?” doesn’t merely fail to tell the story, it is a twisted falsehood in what it fails to reveal as true. McBride called for assistance, she gave clear and lawful orders with verbal commands and gestures repeatedly. She had injured persons who needed her immediate attention, and bystanders who could easily have been attacked by Hernandez if he was successful in taking the officer out of commission, or by making a sudden turn. She had already retreated to create more distance as he continued his intentional, rapid advance. She fired and then assessed for further threat. Seeing that Hernandez was able and purposeful to continue his attack even after being shot, McBride fired multiple times to ensure that his attack would be stopped. Not knowing what condition Hernandez was in, whether he was impervious to pain because of drugs or adrenaline, or perhaps even wearing body armor, the multiple additional shots were tactically sound, yet saving some rounds if still needed.

The media made much of Officer McBride’s status as a top gun in her academy class and other shooting competitions. She was known for her speed and accuracy, characteristics that may have saved her life and others when she was attacked. McBride’s response to this multiple injury crash scene that turned into an ambush can serve as an example of dealing with multiple sensory inputs, putting innocent citizens’ safety first, exercising training to prevent the use of deadly force with repositioning and clear commands, and stopping a violent attack by lawful and necessary means.

So, of course, McBride and the LAPD are being sued.

Attorneys are arguing that the lawsuit should not proceed after a finding that qualified immunity is attached to McBride’s actions. Qualified immunity is applied to unique situations where officers must make rapid decisions for which there are no clear operational or legal absolutes of which the officer should have been aware. The case is now on appeal to the 9th Federal District court on that question.

Among the documents and many court precedents being offered is a friend of the court brief from the National Police Association (NPA). The brief offers expert opinion on the human performance factors of high-stress decision-making as well as a lengthy record of case law upholding the courts’ recognition of the folly of second-guessing officers facing such decisions. Upholding the application of qualified immunity in this case is important to the future of any law enforcement officers who will be faced with the decision of a lifetime.

– Chief Joel F. Shults, Ed.D


Share and speak up for justice, law & order...
Tags: Chief Joel F. ShultsDaniel HernandezLAPDmust-readNPAToni McBride
Law Officer Network

Law Officer Network

The Law Officer Network is a team of writers, editors, and media professionals who support law enforcement agencies—and help them speak up for justice, law, and order. The Network provides hyper-local news, editorials, and analysis that mainstream news and social media typically censor and ignore.

Related Posts

NASCAR

NASCAR goes woke, stops race team from honoring police

August 12, 2022
North Carolina deputy

North Carolina Deputy deputy shot and killed

August 12, 2022
Marshawn Lynch

Bodycam video shows police pull non-compliant Marshawn Lynch from car during DUI arrest

August 11, 2022
Carla Jefferson

Cop-hating Florida woman calls police 11,000 times in one year to bash LEOs

August 11, 2022
Seara Burton

Indiana police officer in ‘very critical condition, fighting for her life,’ following shooting during traffic stop

August 11, 2022
officer shot

California police officer shot in face, two others wounded before suspect surrenders following lengthy standoff

August 11, 2022
Load More

Latest Articles

Trump is ‘ENCOURAGING’ release of search warrant docs

August 12, 2022
Christopher M Flores

Well-known California coach arrested for sexually assaulting minors, police say

August 12, 2022
NASCAR

NASCAR goes woke, stops race team from honoring police

August 12, 2022
North Carolina deputy

North Carolina Deputy deputy shot and killed

August 12, 2022
Marshawn Lynch

Bodycam video shows police pull non-compliant Marshawn Lynch from car during DUI arrest

August 11, 2022
Carla Jefferson

Cop-hating Florida woman calls police 11,000 times in one year to bash LEOs

August 11, 2022
Load More

Weekly E-Newsletter

Subscribe—and get the latest news and editorials direct from Law Officer each week!

[newsletter_form type="minimal"]

MUST READ

NASCAR

NASCAR goes woke, stops race team from honoring police

August 12, 2022
North Carolina deputy

North Carolina Deputy deputy shot and killed

August 12, 2022
Marshawn Lynch

Bodycam video shows police pull non-compliant Marshawn Lynch from car during DUI arrest

August 11, 2022
Carla Jefferson

Cop-hating Florida woman calls police 11,000 times in one year to bash LEOs

August 11, 2022
Seara Burton

Indiana police officer in ‘very critical condition, fighting for her life,’ following shooting during traffic stop

August 11, 2022
Load More

JOIN THE FIGHT

SAFEGUARD RECRUITING

Police Officers Needed – Entry level and lateral applicants wanted!

February 14, 2022

Deputy Sheriff

February 3, 2022

Dispatcher

January 25, 2022

Deputy Sheriff (POST Certified)

January 25, 2022

BE COURAGEOUS

FIND MORE…

Law Officer

© 2021 LawOfficer.com

LawOfficer.com

  • Home
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy Policy
  • Corrections
  • Contact

Speak up for justice, law & order

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • About
    • Authors
  • Articles
    • Archives
    • Chaplain
    • Crime & Controversy
    • Community
    • Cop Humor
    • Editorial
    • Op-ed
    • Gear & Technology
    • Investigations
    • Laws & Legal
    • Leadership
    • News
    • Officer Down
    • On Duty
    • Tactics
  • Network
    • Illinois Network
    • Minneapolis Network
    • Tulsa Network
    • Wauwatosa Network
    • Learn more
  • Training
  • Jobs
  • Contact

© 2021 LawOfficer.com