Last month in Leading the Boss–No Authority? Try Influence, we looked at some ways you can lead your boss, as well as other officers and staff, even if you’re not in a command or supervisory position. This month, we’ll continue to look at ways you can lead your boss.
Intention Counts
Leading the boss isn’t brown nosing or manipulation. It’s about building a relationship and pattern of communication with your boss that produces the best results for you, your boss and the department. It’s about taking the popular notion of servant leadership and applying it up. That means you don’t lead up with the purpose of advancing your and your boss’s careers or personal success. Your purpose in leading up is to advance the mission of policing–serving and protecting your communities.
Look in the Mirror First
You may think it’s the boss’s job to lead. But, unless you just entered the academy from living at home with Mom and Dad, you’ve probably already learned that the path to supervisory positions doesn’t always lead to good leaders. And excellent leaders, such as you, aren’t always in command positions. Your boss’s limitations don’t have to be yours.
To lead up, first take an honest look at what baggage you might be bringing to your relationship with the boss. Research shows we often engage in fundamental attribution error. We tend to assume that other people’s faults come from internal, fundamental flaws, but our own faults are due to temporary environmental factors.
For example, when the chief leads poorly, we believe that she does so intentionally or is inherently a bad leader. When we perform poorly, we’re simply making a mistake because of external factors like pressure, insufficient resources or training.
To unpack your possible fundamental attribution error baggage, ask yourself, “How do I relate to authority figures?” Do I:
- Resent?
- Need to please?
- Over-depend?
- Over-defer?
- Avoid?
- Feel helpless?
- Effectively partner with?
I’m sure you believe you have good reasons for whichever way you relate, but the question is: Which way gains the most for you, the boss, the department and the mission? If you want to effectively partner, ask yourself, “If I was truly in partnership with this person, how would I treat him/her?”
Don’t assume that because the chief or your supervisor asks you for what you think is too much information that they don’t trust you. The request may have more to do with how they process information or make decisions.
Develop a Winning Strategy
How many of you think it would serve you well to go into a street confrontation focused on how unfair the conditions were and expecting to lose? How many of you do just that with your interactions and relationships with the brass?
Peter Drucker, one of the world’s foremost business leader gurus, wrote, “Few managers [or officers] seem to realize how important it is to manage the boss or, worse, believe that it can’t be done at all. They bellyache about the boss but do not even try to manage him (or her). Yet managing the boss is fairly simple–indeed, generally quite a bit simpler than managing subordinates.”
Adapting Drucker’s advice in his landmark The Practice of Management, an officer should spell out in writing:
- His own goals;
- What he sees as the boss’s objectives;
- What he must do himself to attain these goals;
- The things within his own unit or shift he considers the major obstacles;
- The things his immediate supervisor and the department do that help him;
- The things that hamper him; and
- What he proposes to do during the next year to reach his goals.
Then the officer needs to get his boss to sign on. That’s partnering and it leaves little room for confusion or second-guessing.
But the dialogue shouldn’t stop there. At least once a year, the officer should ask his boss (or bosses):
- What do I do (and if he is a supervisor, what do my people do) that helps you do your job?
- What do I/we do that makes your job more difficult?
For example, if community-oriented policing is high on your boss’s agenda, frame your goals and results in terms of benefits to community-oriented policing. If you’re spending a lot of time on work that’s hard to frame in terms of what’s important to your boss, ask yourself why. Then consider how you might approach your work (e.g., highway patrol and traffic enforcement) and add a component of community-oriented policing to it.
The Addison Police Department in Illinois is an excellent example of a traffic enforcement unit that incorporates community-oriented policing as an integral part of its mission.
George Bernard Shaw said, “The single biggest problem in communication is the illusion that it has taken place.” In addition to figuring out what’s important to the boss, you need to understand how to communicate with her. Watch how she communicates. She probably does it the way she likes best. Consider:
- Is she most concerned about results, people, reasons or procedures?
- Is she authoritarian, democratic, self-directed or systematic?
- How does she like to be updated or alerted–email, voicemail, drop by, formal memo?
- Does she prefer a scheduled meeting or a spontaneous discussion?
- Does she require the whole story with lots of detail, brief highlights or quick summary with supporting documentation ready, if needed?
- How often does she want to be communicated with–daily, weekly?
- How does she process information? Listeners prefer to be briefed in person so they can ask questions. Readers want to process written information first, and then meet to discuss.
- Decision-making styles also vary. With highly involved bosses, touch base frequently. With bosses who like to delegate, advise them of important decisions, as needed, after you’ve made them.
Grow Yourself
Be curious. Read, study, observe and listen, and then ask good questions. Last month’s article addressed some good general questions. Visit the website for the International Association of Chiefs of Police. Surf the Internet for top concerns of police supervisors. Get specific with questions about the concerns of law enforcement leadership. You’ll be more interesting and your questions may elicit fresh ideas. Your boss will feel like you’re concerned about and improve everyone’s work and that’s leading up.
Seek responsibility. Find holes in your department before your boss notices them and then fill them. You’ll get a reputation for going beyond the call of duty and putting the mission first. Just make sure you don’t short-change your described duties while taking in more.
It’s About the Work
Leading up may enhance your career but it’s not about you. It’s about the work, which gets done greatly, or not, by the officers and staff in the department. It’s about putting the boss, everyone else in the department and the community first. As a friend of a friend of mine once said, “You can accomplish a lot if you don’t care who gets the credit.”

















