AUSTIN, Texas — The Austin Police Department has eliminated the standalone minimum passing score requirement on the written portion of promotional exams for the ranks of sergeant and lieutenant. Officers can now advance to the next stage of the process, and potentially qualify for promotion, even with a failing written score, provided their combined score with a role-play assessment meets a 70 threshold.
Under the previous system, candidates needed a score of at least 70 out of 100 on the written job-knowledge exam to proceed to an “assessment center,” a series of role-play and practical exercises evaluating leadership, communication, and other skills. Only those who cleared the written exam advanced. The 2024 Meet and Confer Agreement between the City of Austin and the Austin Police Association, which took effect in late October 2024, changed this. City presentation materials on the agreement list the updates under “Enhancements to Promotions,” explicitly including “Increased diversity opportunities for Promotions,” a combined written test and assessment center passing score of 70% (described as a Kroll Report recommendation), and equalized (50/50) weighting of the written exam and assessment center scores (also a Kroll recommendation).
Official notices for recent exams reflect the change. A May 2025 notice for the Police Lieutenant Assessment Center states that candidates who sat for the written examination are qualified to participate and that “There shall be no minimum passing score for the written examination to participate.” Similar language has appeared in related materials. After both components are scored, the eligibility list is created from the combined results (with additional points for seniority, education, and other factors possible under the agreement).
An officer who scores, for example, 40 on the written exam but performs strongly enough in the assessment center to bring the 50/50 average to 70 or higher can now qualify for the promotional eligibility list. Previously, that written score would have ended the process.
The changes stem from recommendations in a 2022 Kroll Associates report commissioned by the City of Austin’s Office of Police Oversight and City Manager’s Office. That multi-phase review examined use of force, public interactions, recruitment, selection, and promotions. Kroll found that the written promotional test “may have an adverse impact on candidates of color” and noted that research generally shows assessment centers produce lower disparate impact than written tests. The firm recommended reconsidering test components and weighting. City officials discussing the labor agreement have described the promotional adjustments as important for diversity and consistent with the Kroll findings. Kroll’s work for the city on APD issues involved contracts and amendments totaling well into the millions of dollars across phases focused on discrimination, training, and related matters.
The city has framed the updates as part of broader efforts to enhance hiring and promotions while complying with the Austin Police Oversight Act and addressing recruitment and retention. Critics of the change argue it lowers standards for leadership positions in a public-safety role; supporters point to reduced barriers and the assessment center’s focus on practical skills as better measures of supervisory ability with less adverse impact by race or ethnicity.
The 2024 agreement runs through September 2029. Promotional eligibility lists continue to be generated through the combined process, and the department continues to administer both written exams and assessment centers through contractors such as I/O Solutions.











