• Home
  • About
    • Authors
  • Advertise
  • Right To Bear
  • Articles
    • Leadership
    • Tactics
    • Officer Down
    • Editorial
    • Op-ed
    • Chaplain
    • News
  • Network
    • Learn more
  • Training
  • Contact
No Result
View All Result
Law Officer
Law Officer
No Result
View All Result

Future of Policing: More Security Guards and Fewer Cops

July 20, 2008
byLaw Officer
Share and speak up for justice, law & order...

"Our ignorance of history causes us to slander our own times."

–Gustave Flaubert

Watch the nightly news on any particular uneventful day and you come away with the same dismal information: We are in trouble. The economy is in shambles, parents are killing their own children, war continues, presidential candidates are making their usual campaign promises that will never materialize, and gas prices are causing most of us to choose between money spent on food or driving to work. Fiscally, government agencies are fighting a losing battle too. For police agencies, budgets are cut and open positions remain unfilled (or worse, layoffs) while calls for service climb and demands increase. Fundamentally, I would argue, American policing methodology needs to change due to a multitude of reasons, and should be responsive to our national conditions. Our world is much different today then how it has been, and we are never going back to the way it used to be.

Historical Policing Partnership: The Pinkertons

It has been done before, and with great success. In 1850, the North-Western Policing Agency (NWPA) was founded by famed private detective Allan Pinkerton, who at the time was the Chicago Police Department's first detective. Eventually, the NWPA evolved into the well known "Pinkerton National Detective Agency," which augmented the Chicago Police with hunting down thieves and burglars within their assigned sectors of the young, but bustling city. World history tells us that this is not the first time a private entity has protected the general public, but in terms of American law enforcement history it is significant. Enter the time period of the Civil War, and Pinkerton Private Detectives were, in 1861, protecting then-President Abraham Lincoln as an early form of the "secret service," while simultaneously tasked with performing certain military intelligence functions against the Confederate Army of the South.

Security and Law Enforcement: Modern Team Policing

Today, the City of Oakland, California finds itself in the unique position of experimenting, over an 18-month period, how to infuse the services of the city police force with officers from a contract security firm. According to Laura Spadanuta, whose report titled "Patrols Gone Private" for Security Management Magazine, this measure is out of desperation due to "a police shortage and high crime rates" affecting the city. Legally, city council provided for the pilot program to draw on public tax monies to pay for the armed security officers. The officers have a defined mission in that they focus their foot patrols to "commercial corridors", and they will closely coordinate their activities with the city police.

However, there are some concerns. First, having armed security officers is actually more of a problem to the private contractor, due to liability and insurance underwriting, than to local government. Secondly, the security officers will not be specially empowered to have arrest authority, since, in the words of Chief Paul Johnson, California Bureau of Security and Investigative Services, "..the definition of a security officer under California law is two words: observe and report." Finally, and probably most significant, the city contract will be negotiated to insulate the municipality from liability exposure that instead will be absorbed by the private firms, because public law enforcement officers have qualified immunity under federal law where as private security does not.

After the trial period, the experiment will be thoroughly reviewed to measure effectiveness, and the prevailing thought today is that the initiative will become an alternative policing model for other cash strapped communities across the nation.

Measuring Change: Will It Work?

Yes. It has been done before. Should these public/private partnerships continue where commercial establishments, gated communities or special interest or activity groups start assuming increasingly more responsibility for their unique protection needs? From my position as an educator, trainer and former professional law enforcement officer the answer is undoubtedly, "Yes." Reason? We have no other choice. There are simply too many competing primary interests to our limited resources within our governmental budgets at any level. Society needs to assume a greater role in protecting itself, an idea that is nothing new, just forgotten. Peel's principles are as relevant today as they were 179 years ago when first penned by Sir Robert himself.


Share and speak up for justice, law & order...
Law Officer

Law Officer

Law Officer is the only major law enforcement publication and website owned and operated by law enforcement—for law enforcement and supporters of justice, law, and order. This unique facet makes Law Officer much more than just a publishing company, but a true advocate for the law enforcement profession.

Related Posts

Respect in Police Training Is a Leadership Issue

November 15, 2026

Austin Police Eliminate Passing Score for Promotional Exams

November 15, 2026
The New York County Supreme Court at Foley Square, bearing George Washington’s words, “The true administration of justice is the firmest pillar of good government.” Retracing Washington’s footsteps—from his inauguration at Federal Hall to his prayer at St. Paul’s Chapel—Vincent J. Bove and his wife, Lily, encountered a timeless principle: justice, truth, and public trust are essential to ethical policing.

Credit: Vincent J. Bove for Reawakening America LLC

An Encounter with America: Manhattan, the Founding Principles, and the Heart of 21st-Century Policing

November 11, 2026
Lily Bove shares a moment with U.S. Navy personnel at the Veterans Day Parade in Manhattan on November 11, 2016, reflecting the personal connection between the American public and those who serve in the armed forces.

Photo credit: Vincent J. Bove for Reawakening America LLC.

The Veteran Behind the Badge: Honoring America’s Military and the Legacy of Service in 21st-Century Policing

November 11, 2026
Vincent J. Bove addresses members of the NYPD Times Square Unit during their roll call at the Midtown South Precinct on October 30, 2026, sharing reflections on attitude, mission, fortitude, and the human dimension of 21st-century policing.

Photo credit: Police Officer Rawson Jackson, for Reawakening America LLC.

The NYPD’s Midtown South Precinct and Times Square Unit: Attitude, Mission, Fortitude

November 4, 2026
Vincent J. Bove addressing NYPD officers on ethical leadership, morale, and emotional fortitude during a precinct engagement at the 46th Precinct in the Bronx on March 15, 2026. The initiative was made possible through the leadership of Sergeant Warren Golden.

Photo credit: NYPD Officer Theodore Cecchini, for Reawakening America LLC.

From a Crisis of Character to an Ethical Renaissance: Moral Leadership in 21st-Century Policing

November 2, 2026
Load More

Latest Articles

Respect in Police Training Is a Leadership Issue

November 15, 2026

Austin Police Eliminate Passing Score for Promotional Exams

November 15, 2026
The New York County Supreme Court at Foley Square, bearing George Washington’s words, “The true administration of justice is the firmest pillar of good government.” Retracing Washington’s footsteps—from his inauguration at Federal Hall to his prayer at St. Paul’s Chapel—Vincent J. Bove and his wife, Lily, encountered a timeless principle: justice, truth, and public trust are essential to ethical policing.

Credit: Vincent J. Bove for Reawakening America LLC

An Encounter with America: Manhattan, the Founding Principles, and the Heart of 21st-Century Policing

November 11, 2026
Lily Bove shares a moment with U.S. Navy personnel at the Veterans Day Parade in Manhattan on November 11, 2016, reflecting the personal connection between the American public and those who serve in the armed forces.

Photo credit: Vincent J. Bove for Reawakening America LLC.

The Veteran Behind the Badge: Honoring America’s Military and the Legacy of Service in 21st-Century Policing

November 11, 2026
Vincent J. Bove addresses members of the NYPD Times Square Unit during their roll call at the Midtown South Precinct on October 30, 2026, sharing reflections on attitude, mission, fortitude, and the human dimension of 21st-century policing.

Photo credit: Police Officer Rawson Jackson, for Reawakening America LLC.

The NYPD’s Midtown South Precinct and Times Square Unit: Attitude, Mission, Fortitude

November 4, 2026
Vincent J. Bove addressing NYPD officers on ethical leadership, morale, and emotional fortitude during a precinct engagement at the 46th Precinct in the Bronx on March 15, 2026. The initiative was made possible through the leadership of Sergeant Warren Golden.

Photo credit: NYPD Officer Theodore Cecchini, for Reawakening America LLC.

From a Crisis of Character to an Ethical Renaissance: Moral Leadership in 21st-Century Policing

November 2, 2026
Load More

Weekly E-Newsletter

Subscribe—and get the latest news and editorials direct from Law Officer each week!

[newsletter_form type="minimal"]

Strength To Serve

BE COURAGEOUS

Protect Your Privacy

FIND MORE…

Law Officer

© 2024 LawOfficer.com

LawOfficer.com

  • Home
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy Policy
  • Corrections
  • Contact

Speak up for justice, law & order

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • About
    • Authors
  • Advertise
  • Right To Bear
  • Articles
    • Leadership
    • Tactics
    • Officer Down
    • Editorial
    • Op-ed
    • Chaplain
    • News
  • Network
    • Learn more
  • Training
  • Contact

© 2024 LawOfficer.com